
I have visited hundreds of churches, and I have discovered that some churches may have “grace” in their name, but not in their DNA. They don’t provide what they’re advertising.
Which is a shame, because grace is what the world desperately needs.
Grace is Christianity’s defining characteristic. Grace is what separates us from every manmade religion and philosophy. By definition, every church has a measure of grace. It’s just that some dilute grace with other things. They mix grace with law and end up lukewarm.
How do you tell if a church is preaching grace or law or some unholy mixture of both? You just need to listen. You keep your ears open for the keywords of grace and law.
A church that preaches law will emphasize words like: work, duty, debt, obligation, perform, produce, lack, service, strive, struggle, suffer, obey, sin, confess, convict, judgment, commandment, guilt, condemnation, penalty and punish.
A church that preaches grace will use words like; love, faith, rest, forgiven, favor, receive, believe, righteous, justified, accepted, abide, abundance, fullness, fellowship, beloved, sons, children of God, good news, hope, blessed, freedom, spiritual, new creation, life, light, truth, power and Jesus.
And a church that is mixing grace with law will indiscriminately use words from both lists.
What is a grace Bible church?
Churches come in all shapes and flavors, but here are 8 signs that a church gets grace:
- Grace churches preach Jesus and nothing but Jesus
- Grace churches reveal a God who loves you like a Father
- Grace churches esteem the words of Jesus
- Grace churches esteem the law and the purpose for which it is given
- Grace churches understand that obedience is a fruit not a root
- Grace churches empower people to overcome sin
- Grace churches promote security and trust
- Grace churches look like Jesus, smell like Jesus, walk like Jesus, and talk like Jesus
A grace church is attractive to sinners and unappealing to the self-righteous. It is a place where the prodigals come home and the zealots stay out. It is a family where the broken are made whole, the captives are freed, and all are loved.
What is a graceless church?
Sometimes to accentuate a positive, it helps to highlight a negative. Here are 8 signs a church doesn’t get grace:
- Graceless churches are self-conscious
- Graceless churches are not sure if God likes them
- Graceless churches speak the faithless language of lack and longing
- Graceless churches are sin conscious
- Graceless churches are law-minded
- Graceless churches think grace just is for sinners
- Graceless churches treat people as resources
- Graceless churches are insecure and anxious
A graceless church is attractive to the self-righteous but unappealing to sinners. It is a place the zealots call home but the prodigals avoid. It is a place where the sheep are fleeced and the poor are exploited. It stinks of self-righteousness and it is a terrible advertisement for Jesus.
Not every church is the same which is why you need to read the label:
God gives grace to the graceless
Now before you think I am some self-appointed arbiter of church quality, let me confess that as a pastor I embodied all the attributes on the graceless list.
Sure, I preached grace, but I balanced it with law. I preached faith, but I also preached dead works. Since I did not interpret scripture through the lens of the cross, I was like a pharmacist indiscriminately dispensing medicine and poison.
I loved the Lord with all my heart and I was doing the best I could, but I was a mixed-up preacher with an incomplete grasp of grace.
I did not preach the gospel of grace but a mixed-grace gospel that combined the unmerited favor of God with the wage of human-effort. I understood that we were saved by grace, but I did not realize we are kept by grace.
I did not appreciate what made the new covenant new.
Maybe this sounds like you or your pastor or your church. If so, I have good news. Jesus loves mixed-up Christians and graceless churches.
You may be tempted to give up on your pastor – “he doesn’t get it” – but Jesus never will. He didn’t give up on me and he won’t give up on you.
We are all on a journey. Maybe you get grace, or maybe you’re still figuring it out. Maybe all this talk of grace and law unsettles you. Fear not. Here is a truth you can cling to: He who began a good work in you (and your pastor and your church) will carry it on unto completion.
Jesus is making his church glorious and beautiful.
—
Seems a lot of you are keen for this one. The Grace Bible: Ephesians has broken all records for my most pre-ordered book on Kindle.
Good news – it comes out next week in all formats!